Mere Heterodoxy
Heterodoxy refers to views that differ from strictly orthodox views, but retain sufficient faithfulness to the original doctrine to avoid heresy. I try not to be heretical. Mostly.
Sunday, May 13, 2012
Hear What the Spirit is Saying to the Church
Monday, January 2, 2012
Second Person Plural
Growing up in Church the Advent wreath was always one of my favorite traditions, if for no other reason than it allowed me to gauge exactly how much time there was until I got presents. We never used the old Advent calendars, which kept a day by day countdown to the birth of Christ, the wreath gauges our progress in weeks. Weeks which, as kids, seem like little eternities and every Sunday a candle was lit meant that we were one less eon away from Jesus’ coming. Or from presents. I’ll leave you to guess which was more exciting to my childhood self.
Regardless of my motivations, the Advent wreath was a countdown to joy, a countdown to those occasions that contain the majority of my most wonderful memories, and yet, on those days in between Sundays, on those days when the wreath sat in that unoccupied sanctuary with its blackened wicks and uneven lengths of wax those little eternities got longer, and joy seemed forever away.
Our texts today invite us into those spaces. They invite us into waiting, into that childlike sense of eternity that our hectic schedules no longer allow us to savor. Our texts today demand that we sigh for the coming of joy again, and if we merely allow ourselves to sit back and enjoy the relative comfort of our pews I fear they will pass us by and the profound movement of the Spirit crying out to us will pass like Christmas lights fading in a rear view mirror.
This takes a remarkably uncomfortable degree of honesty. We have to acknowledge the fact that we are waiting in a broken world. We have to look amongst our community and see that sin still pervades us, that death still claims those who we hold dear. We need to want for joy like a child wanting for Christmas if only so that when we hear the proclamation “Comfort, O Comfort” we know what that longing feels like.
The fact that we’re English speakers doesn’t do us any favors in approaching Isaiah 40. From the translation we might expect that this is some divine proclamation of God bestowing divine comfort through our time of trial. We might think that comfort here is a noun, that it’s a thing that God is bestowing on us in the midst of our tumultuous life, we just have to take it in and be thankful. This, however, is not the case. “Comfort” here, is a verb. It’s something that needs to be done. That being said, it can still seem like the comforting in the passage is something for the prophet to do. Just like it can often seem like comforting is something reserved for the Priests among us. It can seem like God is making a call to good Pastoral care. Again, our language fails us here, because, Y’all, I’m afraid that God is a bit more southern than our Bibles let on.
The Hebrew here is presenting a thought that isn’t easily communicated North of the Mason-Dixon line, or west of the Mississippi. God is addressing the community like my mother raised in may’retta. “Comfort my people, Y’all, Comfort them. Says your God. Speak tenderly to Jerusalem. And tell her she has served her term, that her penalty is paid, that she has received from the Lord’s hand double for all her sins.” God is speaking to us. She’s speaking to all of us. In the same way a mother’s call booms down the street at suppertime God’s call lifts off of the page and into our reality beckoning us to a place of renewal and divine restoration. Naturally we have to object. Isaiah does. “What shall I cry?” Do you not see that we are grass? That we are sinful and broken and grieving? We are waiting for the word to break into our lives in the birth of our Savior, but until then. This is honesty. This is a frank assessment of our situation as fallen creatures that is as true for Isaiah as it is for us. What then do we do with this call?
We do what John the Baptist does.
Don’t take this to mean that I’m recommending locusts and wild honey and hair shirts. John’s ministry looks an awful lot like the Church on its best days. John proclaims the forgiveness of sins. John offers hope, and calls for a dramatic re-orienting our lives to the reality of God. What’s more John does this in the face of Roman occupation, religious corruption, and civil unrest. John stands tall among the grass that we are. And it is precisely because he stands tall that he is cut short so early. And, even though, his time was brief his message rings out a truth that echoes in eternity, the truth that there is a loving and forgiving God. All that is required is that we turn and face that truth.
This is, on our best days, the message of the church. Like John we’re called to proclaim it and offer the healing waters of baptism to all who feel so called. Like John we’re to stand in the wilderness, at the margins and ring out a truth that stretches beyond us and our condition. Like John we are to be a comfort to so many who believe that they have nothing beyond the waiting, we are to point them to the one who is coming after us whose sandals we are not worthy to untie. There’s work to do in the waiting. And while we can still watch, and hope for, and ready ourselves for that moment which will come like a thief in the night we can not ignore those words that ring out past the pages of scripture: A voice cries out: “In the wilderness prepare the way of the Lord, make straight in the desert a highway for our God. Every valley shall be lifted up, and every mountain and hill shall be made low; the uneven ground shall become level, and the rough places a plain. Then the glory of the Lord shall be revealed, and all people shall see it together, for the mouth of the Lord has spoken.”
A voice in the wilderness , “Cry Out!”
That voice is us, y’all.
Miles Davis and the Life of Faith
I had my first “Oh my God, I just had a religious experience” experience while listening to Jazz. I was driving home a little too late from a friends house and I pulled out onto A1A in Cocoa Beach. I was the only one on the road. It was that kind of ride where you know that all you have to do is keep the car on the pavement. As long as you keep the wheels straight you can disappear. You can sink back into the machine and just be for a bit. We don’t get many moments like that here in Atlanta.
The boardwalk lights were dead. The port had shut down for the night, and the bars surrounding it were getting ready to turn off the neon. I was listening to Miles Davis’ Kind of Blue, not with any attention, until the first chords to Blue in Green started playing. I leaned back in my chair, and then sank into the dashboard lights, little blurs of orange and green letting me know that the one job I had was still being done. I suddenly felt cared for. Loved. Not like an immense ecstatic love, but like there was some cosmic presence drawing me from the periphery of existence into direct view. Like God was focusing in on me in my 92 Toyota Celica and saying, “Here’s looking at you, kid.”
It only lasted as long the time it takes to blow a note through a muted trumpet, but something was changed in me. Something was awakened, and I spent the rest of the ride home trying to figure out what it was.
I thought it had something to do with the song. After all, we all know that if Jesus listens to anything on his heavenly iPod its Miles Davis. I kept listening to Blue in Green, I kept trying to recreate that experience, and it wasn’t happening. I was convinced there was something about that combination of notes, that chord progression something in there triggered it. It had to have been the song.
I went to Barnes and Noble the next day. I was an aspiring Jazz guitarist at the time (something I have only barely held onto) and I could read the music well enough to get further in touch with whatever tonal concoction Mr. Davis wrote that so affected me. I bought a book that had the sheet music to the song, ran out to my car and opened it, furiously turning to Blue in Green. Furiously looking for the secret to my divine encounter the night before. I finally found the page, and it hit me like wall.
There were only two lines on the page. Only 12 bars of music and the skeleton of a melody.
I had no clue where to jump into it. I had no idea where to go from there. Blue in Green is a six-minute song, and this book was only giving me 12 bars that would fill half a minute at best if I took the song at tempo. I had no way in. There was too much improvisation, too much extemporaneous beauty. The text itself wasn’t going to be enough.
We can come to the Bible like this too. We have those texts that make us feel overjoyed to be worshiping such a loving, just and compassionate God. We have texts that sing to us off the page, and while we are encountering them we feel embraced in that all loving presence. Then we close our Bibles, go about our lives only to return, opening the text that gave us so much joy, and we see those 12 impenetrable bars staring us in the face. We have no way in.
The first 12 verses of Matthew’s 23 Chapter came to me like this, and not without good reason. These twelve verses we read today make the highlight reel of verses that have inspired virulent anti-semitism throughout Christian history. The make it far too easy for us to look at the “scribes and Pharisees” and write of the entirety of Judaism as legalistic hypocrisy. For much of our history this passage has caused Christians to look at Jewish prayer shawls and wrapping teffelim (the practice of binding passages of Torah to the arms and forehead) as clear signs that this nation of God had missed the boat, and we could supplant them and end their blatant hypocrisy in violent ways. Ways that made we Christians the hypocrites. For far too much of our history we proclaimed God’s unlimited love all the while proclaiming that the actions of a people deserved unlimited condemnation.
We have some confessing to do when we think about everything that this text carries with it. Especially when we as Christians take on many of the same behaviors condemned in the passage. It’s a laundry list of common practice. And it should give us pause. We have all heard stories of those unduly burdened in the pews as those placing the yoke walk away easy. We all know the crowds where the phrase “Good Christian Man, or Good Christian Woman” instantly grants one a place of honor, if not at the dinner table, then it at least privileges us over others who are conversely “good for nothing.” And there we find ourselves. There is nothing new under the sun.
So there it is. 12 verses hitting us like a wall. And, on the face of things, it seems like we’re lacking a way in.
The longer I looked at the Miles Davis piece, the more I listened to the recordings and fumbled my way through those 12 bars the more I realized what it took. I needed to improvise. The way to move past the limits of the page, the way to produce the sound that so moved me on that empty highway did not lie between the lines, it lay outside them.
It is precisely for this reason that I have come to cringe at the phrase “Bible-believing Christian.” We are not bound to a text; we are bound to the risen and living Lord. We come to this building and to this table encountering a God who was and is still with us. We encounter God in a very real way. A way that lets us improvise. We have 12 bars and a melody; It’s up to us to fill it out. To make it sing, to get it to the point that it connects with ourselves and those around us in a way that makes us sink into our seats and feel cared for, feel loved.
The life of faith is a life improvised.
This is not to say we don’t have roots. This is not to say that we can go anywhere with it. The blessing of the text is that we have the limits of a melody, we have a chord progression to follow, we have stories and sayings that we can connect to That we can use to guide and shape our lives together. It’s a blessing, but only if we treat it as such.
The Gospel reading for the day, this problematic, troubling passage, leaves us with one of the most beautiful lines in scripture. “All who exalt themselves will be humbled, and all who humble themselves will be exalted.” There comes a point in every musicians life where they realize that they are doing something that is entirely beyond them they break free from the page, and their fingers move, and they find themselves in the presence of a music that is more than ever could have been put to paper. This is holy improvisation. As we prepare ourselves to come to the table I pray that we would have that same experience, that we would kneel at the rail and find ourselves in the presence of something that is entirely beyond the text. This too, is a holy improvisation. This is the life of faith. Amen.
Thursday, September 29, 2011
Lectionary reflection. 9/29
Friday, September 2, 2011
A Sacristan at the Altar Call: It's More catholic Than We Think.
Monday, August 15, 2011
Fields of Grace
Put in the sickle, for the harvest is ripe! Praise God. His kingdom is coming, his heavenly city is knocking, the New Jerusalem is waiting for him to call us home, and woe to those who aren’t ready! I know I am. I am ready for that kingdom that Jesus tells us is like a man who goes out to scatter seed. And God brings up that seed with no help from man. God, in his grace and power is bringing up his Elect and we don’t know how, but we’re thankful for what he has done in our lives. We’re thankful that he saved us. We’re thankful that we’ll get to sing and shout the victory over those wicked nations that have gathered before us. In Mark 4:29 Jesus is quoting the prophet Joel who tells us what that great day will be like:
“Put in the Sickle, for the harvest is ripe.
Go in, tread, for the wine press is full.
The vats overflow, for their wickedness is great.
Multitudes, multitudes, in the valley of decision!
The sun and the moon are darkened…
…and the stars withdraw their shining…”
I am too comfortable with hearing this message…
We, the Church, are too comfortable with speaking this message…
But we are not alone in this. This message of judgment was a message of hope to those first century Jews who saw the nations under the banner of Rome cover Jerusalem with their pagan symbols and foreign languages. We can hear Joel’s war scroll, as this passage is often called, whispered behind the backs of passing Centurions by those righteous few who were working underground for the liberation of their homeland. To the Zealots, this is a rallying cry; to the Peasants it was a breath of hope. Hope that one day their lands would no longer be called upon to pay tribute to a King or Emperor but to the presence of the living God.
This is the conversation that we enter into when we read Mark 4:29, and even though Mark’s Greek is not as refined as the translators of the Septuagint he is quoting Joel quite directly, Mark’s just saying it with a bit of back-water twang. The ending to this parable was meant to pull up this judgment scene in its hearers with all the vividness and emotion that it arouses. We are supposed to come to this parable with preconceptions. Mark is banking on it. And though it may be a stretch to say that we have the same scriptural memory as Mark’s initial audience we don’t have to work too hard to bring about the emotional weight that the Gospel is trying to pull from us. All we have to do is add a hammer.
Doubtless there are many of us here who can remember the significance of a golden hammer and sickle in the upper left hand corner of a red flag. These two common tools of industry and agriculture came together to form a symbol that contributed to a conflict which kept our world on edge for half of a century.
I can remember taking Marx’s Das Kapital, part of my enlightened 21st century education, home with me and seeing the look of wide eyed astonishment on my grandparents faces as they contemplated the prospect that their grandson might be a communist: A thought, which only 50 years ago would have been spoken in a hushed tone in a coffee shop or shouted across the aisle in the halls of the Senate. My parents, both born during the Cuban Missile Crisis, came to adulthood never expecting to see the year 1980. They lived through high school waiting for that hammer and sickle to rush across the fields of West German barley into a new valley of decision; where fire would rain from the sky in ways that make the harshest prophecy from Revelation seem tame. Even God thought the Hydrogen bomb was a bit harsh.
But we don’t even need to look back that far. Even today we hear parts of the Church touting the deaths of soldiers in Iraq and Afghanistan as the first fruits of God’s harvest of the wicked. We hear daily of the importance of supporting Israel in its quest to carve out a place amongst the nations. We come to this passage with a burden. We come to this parable ready for judgment, but Jesus, as he often does, comes to us with abundant grace.
A person goes out to scatter seed, and after it is in the ground they go to sleep. They don’t touch it. But it grows. And they don’t know how.
There is a great temptation here, in our scientific society, to read this as an example of the simplicity of those in first century Palestine. They didn’t know about the process of germination, about the nutrients in the soil necessary for a good crop, or about the complex process of photosynthesis that would eventually produce the grain. We can say all this with certainty, what we cannot say, however is that first century Palestinians did not know how plants grow. Though they may have been short on the why of the process, it is a great hubris to say that we are better acquainted with agriculture than the contemporaries of Mark, who lived a life so attached to the land that we can scarcely imagine the intimate relationship between the people their land, and their crops.
Those who worked the land at that time would have known better than any of us just how to till the earth before planting. Exactly how to keep harmful weeds out of their field when the stalks came up, what insects to keep away when the grain started to show, and just how tend to the full head that would later appear on the grain. These things, which are for us today specialized knowledge would be facts of life for the masses whom Jesus was addressing. They knew how plants grow. They knew what needed to be done to ensure a fruitful harvest, which is why when the person in our parable does nothing to tend their crop we meet with that phrase of amazement. “…and he does not know how.” Against all common knowledge these plants grow when they should die. They flourish when they should fail. This is God at work, because we haven’t done a thing.
After my high school graduation my father took me on a road trip out west to see the places that became so familiar to him in his years as a long-distance trucker. We were in a Ford Econoline that we had done some work to allow us to fit a full sized bed where the rear two seats should be. We were switching between driving and sleeping in four-hour shifts and were poised to make it from Jacksonville, Florida to Los Angeles in two days.
I had been in the passenger seat since the Lake Ponchatrain bridge when we pulled in to get gas in the small town of Brehenam, Texas. I got out to stretch my legs and kick the tires when I noticed that there was a think layer of grease covering the rear passenger side wheel well that ran up the rear of the van and coated the rear windshield. We found the Ford dealership in town, put the van in the shop, and waited for the diagnostic. We had a cracked bearing seal, which was allowing the spinning tire to fling the entirety of its lubrication along the back of the van. “Yall’s bearing should have seized up about fifty miles back,” the mechanic said. He had next to no idea how we made it there.
The lack of lubrication in the bearing meant that the steel interior of the bearing was heating up to the point at which the moving parts in the wheel casing should have fused themselves together and ceased to move at all. Which, at 70 miles an hour, is not a happy prospect. Both my father and I understand the why but in that particular instance we did not know how we made it to the dealership. We didn’t do a thing, except drive to far. This was God at work.
We all have, at one time or another had those moments where we stand with the sower and scratch our heads. We all have stood in fields of grace. We have all lived in moments of wonder; we carry those moments with us, just as we carry our narratives of judgment and fear. All that we are asked by this parable is that, while we’re waiting for the harvest, while we’re waiting for the sickle, we keep that sense of amazement. That we keep our sense of God at work, beyond anything we have ever expected, beyond all our hopes, fears, and judgments.
May we all stand in fields of grace, a grace that sustains and keeps us in the presence of the living God. In the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, Amen.